Inside META’s New Mule Economy: How Fraud Networks Now Blend Starlink, eSIMs, and Device Muling to Evade Banks

If you think money mules in 2025 are still hiding behind basic VPNs, think again. In the Middle East, Turkey, and Africa (the META region), mule operators have leveled up. They’re mixing digital deception with physical logistics in a way that feels more like a supply chain than a scam. And they’re getting fast, adaptive, and frustratingly good at looking “normal.”

Here’s why that matters: banks and fintechs are under pressure to stop more fraud with less friction. Regulators expect better outcomes. Criminals are now reshaping tactics every few months. If you run fraud, risk, or compliance, this is the new battleground—and it’s already at your doorstep.

In this article, we’ll unpack what security researchers are seeing on the ground, why mule networks have gotten smarter, and how you can respond. We’ll also explain the tactics in plain language, so your teams can align around the threat without drowning in jargon.

Let’s dive in.

What Is a Money Mule—and Why Is META a Hotbed?

A money mule is someone who moves illicit funds on behalf of criminals. Sometimes they know. Often, they don’t. They might be promised quick cash, a “remote job,” or a “business opportunity.” Increasingly, they’re onboarded with real contracts and onboarding kits that mimic legitimate employers.

META is a focal point right now for a few reasons:

Rapid fintech growth and expanding digital banking adoption
Fragmented regulatory enforcement across borders
High youth unemployment in certain markets, which mule recruiters exploit
Proximity to conflict zones and smuggling corridors

None of this means banks in META are behind. It means adversaries see opportunity—and they move fast. Europol and Interpol have warned for years that mule networks are central to fraud supply chains, not just side players. See: Europol on money muling and INTERPOL on money mules.

The Evolution: From Simple VPNs to Logistics-Grade Fraud

Security researchers at Group-IB recently detailed how mule networks in META have evolved. Two years ago, the typical mule relied on:

Basic VPNs and proxy tools to mask IP addresses
Low-effort identity theft to open accounts
Uncoordinated, one-off transfers

Banks adapted. IP reputation checks, device fingerprinting, and tighter KYC made those tricks less effective. So mule operators pivoted.

By 2023, the playbook changed:

Roaming SIM cards and eSIMs to bypass “out-of-region” checks
Starlink terminals for internet access in remote or flagged areas
GPS spoofing to make devices appear where banks expected them

One of the largest groups, reportedly operating from Syria and Turkey, used stolen identities, eSIMs, and GPS manipulation to open hundreds of accounts. Researchers say funds connected to extremist financing were later traced through those channels. That should raise eyebrows far beyond fraud teams. It’s a national security issue, too. The UK has formally recognized the scale and harm of fraud as a strategic threat—see the regulator’s stance on APP scams and reimbursement frameworks from the Payment Systems Regulator and broader context on fraud harms from the UK National Crime Agency.

Then came mid-2024:

Mule networks began physically removing SIM cards from devices between sessions to break “telecom fingerprint” continuity.
A layered model crystallized. So-called “first-layer mules” opened accounts legitimately and behaved like normal customers for weeks or months. They built trust, then passed credentials to overseas operators who ran the laundering.
Fraud groups dressed up these arrangements as legitimate partnerships—with contracts, reimbursement forms, and corporate language—to avoid scrutiny.

Finally, in early 2025, another leap:

Physical device muling. Instead of handing over logins, fraudsters shipped preconfigured smartphones across borders. Device fingerprints stayed consistent, making fraud look like a legitimate customer logging in on the same device—just in a new location.

Behavioral biometrics became a key countermeasure. Subtle signals, like swipe speed, typing rhythm, and transaction cadence, still revealed handovers from one operator to another. When you change the human, you change the behavior—even if the device looks the same. That insight is powerful.

“Fraud leaves patterns,” the Group-IB report notes. “With the right telemetry, even complex schemes can be disrupted.”

The New Mule Stack: Digital Tricks Meet Physical Logistics

Let me explain the modern mule structure in simple terms. Think of it like a relay team:

Layer 1: Account openers. They pass KYC checks. They maintain accounts like model customers. They use local devices and IPs. Nothing fancy.
Layer 2: Laundering operators. They are often offshore. They receive credentials or, increasingly, the physical device. They move money through chains of accounts.
Logistics and HR: Coordinators recruit, coach, and pay first-layer mules. They ship devices. They manage schedules, SOPs, and cover stories.
Compliance camouflage: Front companies and “partnership agreements” paper over the activity. Everything looks structured and reasonable at a glance.

What’s different now is the level of operational discipline. This is not random chaos; it’s an assembly line. When one route gets blocked, they swap parts. SIM edges out? Go eSIM or remove SIMs entirely. IP flagged? Use Starlink or mobile roaming. Device risk growing? Ship the device instead of the credentials.

How Banks Are Being Tricked—And Where the Tells Still Show

Fraudsters know the tripwires: IP reputation, GPS checks, device fingerprints, and ordinary anomaly models. So they try to bypass each signal in turn.

IP and GPS: Roaming SIMs, Starlink, and spoofing tools hide location. But satellite IPs and mobility patterns have distinct signatures. And GPS spoofing often leaves telltale inconsistencies versus Wi-Fi and cellular data. For background on GNSS spoofing trends, see EUSPA on jamming and spoofing.
Telecom fingerprint: Removing SIMs or swapping eSIM profiles aims to break continuity. Yet device hardware, OS build, and sensor characteristics can still bind activity to a single device profile.
Behavioral biometrics: Here’s where deception struggles. A new operator on the same phone still types differently, swipes at a different pace, and navigates with different habits. High-signal behavioral models spot those handovers.
Narrative cover: Contracts and expense forms make schemes look like real business. But graph analytics sees the network, not the paperwork. You can connect devices, merchants, IPs, and payments into maps that reveal the hidden mule clusters.

In short, the scheme is layered, but so are your defenses. As long as your signals talk to each other, gaps are manageable.

The Victim-to-Victim Relay: When Mules Don’t Know They’re Mules

A worrying trend is the “victim relay.” Fraudsters trick Victim A into sending funds to Victim B. They tell B a convincing story—refund, escrow, prize—and ask them to forward the money. B thinks they’re helping a legitimate request. In reality, they’ve become a mule.

This pattern aligns with the surge in Authorized Push Payment (APP) fraud. It weaponizes trust between ordinary people and platforms. The result is more laundering paths and more complexity for investigations. For context and policy developments, see UK Finance’s Fraud – The Facts.

Why This Escalation Matters: From Fraud Losses to National Security

This is no longer “just” a customer service issue. It touches:

Financial stability: Faster movement, larger volumes, and cross-border chains.
Compliance exposure: KYC, AML, and sanctions evasion risks multiply.
National security: Links to extremist financing and organized crime are real, according to researchers and law enforcement.

When fraud becomes a logistics operation, it scales. That’s why the conversation has shifted from individual scams to systemic risk. Interagency and cross-border cooperation are no longer optional. Intelligence sharing via organizations like FS-ISAC is vital.

What Banks and Fintechs Should Do Now

Group-IB’s recommendations match what high-performing fraud teams already know works. The key is execution at scale and speed.

Here’s a practical roadmap.

1) Embrace Multi-Layered Fraud Detection

No single signal is enough. Fuse them.

Network and device: IP reputation, ASN and satellite ranges, device fingerprinting, OS telemetry, sensor checks.
Location integrity: Cross-check GPS with Wi‑Fi and cell tower data. Look for impossible travel and inconsistent mobility.
Telecom metadata: SIM/eSIM changes, roaming status, and MCC/MNC patterns. Treat frequent SIM churn as a risk signal.
Behavioral biometrics: Typing rhythm, gesture dynamics, session flow, dwell times. Calibrate for accessibility and ensure privacy by design.
Transaction and entity risk: Velocity, high-risk merchants, round-trip patterns, and suspicious time-of-day spikes.

For guardrails and identity assurance best practices, see NIST SP 800‑63 Digital Identity Guidelines.

2) Deploy AI-Driven Anomaly Detection—Responsibly

Modern mule rings create weak signals sprinkled across thousands of accounts. Let machine learning connect the dots. But keep humans in the loop.

Use semi-supervised models for novel patterns.
Maintain transparent features for explainability with compliance.
Monitor for bias, drift, and adversarial adaptation.

3) Raise the Bar on KYC and Remote Onboarding

Synthetic identities and manipulated documents are the on-ramp. Tighten it.

Multi-source verification: Document, device, and data-backed corroboration.
Video verification with liveness and challenge-response.
Consistency checks across application and device metadata.
Step-up reviews for risk clusters and shared signals across applications.

For regulatory guidance, review the EBA Guidelines on remote customer onboarding and FATF Recommendations.

4) Graph Analytics to Uncover Mule Networks

Think in graphs, not rows.

Link accounts, devices, merchants, IPs, and beneficiaries.
Score clusters, not just individuals.
Flag “quiet” accounts connected to hot nodes.
Use community detection to surface first-layer mules who look normal in isolation.

For a primer on how graphs boost AML and fraud, explore industry analyses via ACAMS and similar bodies, e.g., ACAMS Today on graph analytics.

5) Build Satellite and GPS Awareness

Starlink and other satellite services change network texture.

Maintain allow/deny lists for satellite ASN ranges where appropriate.
Treat sudden moves from terrestrial to satellite IP as a step-up trigger.
Cross-validate GPS with inertial movement and known satellite footprints.

6) Prepare for Deepfakes and Synthetic Documents

Expect higher-quality fakes. Strengthen defenses now.

Multi-frame liveness checks with motion prompts.
Challenge-response that resists replay.
Cross-field document validation and issuer checks.
Keep an eye on generative AI threat reports. Europol’s “Facing reality of deepfakes” is a useful overview: Europol deepfakes report.

7) Invest in Intelligence Sharing and Feedback Loops

Mule rings cross borders. Your defenses should, too.

Join sector sharing communities like FS-ISAC.
Exchange indicators with telecom partners and payment networks.
Feed confirmed mule events back into your models fast.

8) Train Front-Line Teams and Customers

Human awareness is a force multiplier.

Give customer support and branch staff simple mule red flags.
Run targeted education campaigns for at-risk groups.
Publish “don’t be a mule” guidance consistent with Europol’s public advice.

A 30/60/90-Day Action Plan

If you need a quick-start implementation plan, here’s a pragmatic path.

Day 0–30: Baseline and quick wins
Add satellite ASN lists to IP risk engines.
Turn on alerts for SIM/eSIM churn and roaming anomalies.
Pilot behavioral biometrics on login and high-risk flows.
Stand up a basic graph view for beneficiary networks.
Day 31–60: Expand signal fusion
Correlate GPS with Wi‑Fi triangulation inconsistencies.
Integrate device intelligence with KYC outcomes.
Define step-up policies for device handovers and impossible travel.
Launch a cross-functional mule response playbook (fraud, AML, legal, PR).
Day 61–90: Industrialize and measure
Productionize graph analytics with community scoring.
Add continuous model monitoring and drift detection.
Create an internal “mule indicator” taxonomy and case tagging.
Report KPIs to leadership with clear risk narrative.

KPIs That Matter for Anti-Mule Programs

Measure progress with metrics that track both prevention and precision.

Mule detection precision and recall by cluster
Percentage of fraud blocked via device/behavioral telemetry
Time from mule signal to containment action
False positive rate on “good” customers impacted
Volume of APP fraud routed to “victim relay” patterns (A->B->C)
Percentage of accounts detected pre-loss versus post-loss
Intelligence-sharing contributions and external signals consumed

Don’t Forget the Consumer Angle: How People Get Roped In

Many mules start as victims. That’s tough but true. Clear, simple guidance helps:

Be skeptical of “instant job” offers that require using your bank account or phone.
Never “test transactions” or “hold funds” for strangers or new business contacts.
Refuse to receive money and forward it—even if a story sounds official.
Verify employers and opportunities independently. Use known contact channels.
If you think you’ve been used as a mule, act fast: contact your bank and law enforcement.

For public-facing resources you can share, point customers to INTERPOL’s money mule guidance and national fraud reporting sites in your country.

What’s Next: 2025–2026 Threats to Watch

Expect more of the same—plus a few new twists.

More device muling and “device-as-a-passport” tactics
Better-quality deepfakes for ID and video KYC
Wider use of eSIM profiles and remote provisioning
Satellite connectivity normalization in difficult geographies
Growth in synthetic identity fraud fueling account opening at scale; see the Federal Reserve’s overview: Synthetic identity payments fraud

The throughline is clear: fraud is no longer purely digital. It’s intertwined with human recruitment, logistics, and AI.

Case Study Snapshot: Where Behavioral Biometrics Win

Consider a first-layer mule who looks perfect on paper. Clean KYC. Local IP. Normal spend. After three months, the account starts handling larger transfers to a new beneficiary cluster.

Device fingerprint stays identical. No SIM in the phone anymore. At a glance, it’s the same customer.

But behavioral telemetry shifts:

Shorter session times, higher navigation speed
Reduced error rates in typing but inconsistent dwell times
New swipe vectors on the same screens

No single change proves fraud. Together, they tell a story: someone else is driving this device. Step-up verification triggers, a risk analyst reviews the case, and you contain a mule handover before a major loss.

That’s the model: small signals, fused fast, with human confirmation where it counts.

Helpful Resources and Further Reading

Group-IB research and updates on fraud trends: Group-IB Blog
Europol’s money mule awareness hub: Europol – Money Muling
INTERPOL on money muling: INTERPOL – Money Muling
UK Finance on APP fraud and trends: Fraud – The Facts
PSR APP scams and reimbursement policy: Payment Systems Regulator
NIST Digital Identity Guidelines: NIST SP 800-63
EU Space Programme on GNSS spoofing: EUSPA – Jamming and Spoofing
Europol on deepfakes: Facing reality of deepfakes
FS-ISAC membership and intel sharing: FS-ISAC

FAQs

Q: What is a money mule in banking? A: A money mule moves funds on behalf of criminals. They may be complicit or duped. Mules help launder proceeds from scams, cybercrime, or other illicit activity.

Q: Why are mule networks growing in the META region? A: The combination of fast fintech growth, uneven enforcement across borders, and economic pressures creates fertile ground for recruiters. Criminals also exploit regional connectivity options and logistics routes.

Q: How do roaming SIMs and Starlink help mule operators? A: They blur location signals. Roaming SIMs make a device appear “locally present” across regions. Satellite internet changes IP characteristics and reduces reliance on local infrastructure. Together, they complicate geolocation checks.

Q: What is device muling? A: Instead of sharing credentials, fraudsters ship a preconfigured smartphone to another operator. The device fingerprint stays the same, which can bypass some risk checks. Behavioral biometrics can still spot the operator change.

Q: Can GPS spoofing defeat all location checks? A: No. GPS spoofing can be detected when cross-checked against Wi‑Fi, cell data, motion sensors, and travel patterns. It’s one signal, not a silver bullet.

Q: How can banks detect first-layer mules who look “normal”? A: Use graph analytics to find hidden connections, combine device and telecom metadata, and monitor behavioral shifts around account handovers or unusual beneficiary patterns.

Q: Are deepfakes already impacting KYC? A: Yes, attempts are rising. High-quality liveness checks, challenge-response prompts, and cross-field document validation help counter them. Keep monitoring guidance from regulators and law enforcement.

Q: What should consumers do if they think they’ve been used as a mule? A: Contact your bank immediately, stop forwarding funds, keep records, and report to national fraud authorities. Early action limits harm and may help recover funds.

Q: Is APP fraud really a national security issue? A: The scale of APP fraud and its links to organized crime and other illicit networks have national security implications, according to UK authorities and industry bodies. See guidance from the PSR and context from the NCA.

The Takeaway

Mule operations in META have turned into multi-layer networks that mix digital stealth with real-world logistics. VPNs and proxies were yesterday’s tricks. Today, it’s eSIMs, Starlink, GPS manipulation, and device shipping—wrapped in slick corporate cover stories. But even polished schemes leave patterns. When you fuse IP, GPS, SIM, device, graph, and behavioral signals—and share intelligence—those patterns become visible.

If you run risk, fraud, or compliance, start integrating these layers now. Measure what matters. Train your teams. Support your customers. And keep learning—because the playbook will change again.

Want more insights like this? Subscribe for practical breakdowns on fraud, identity, and risk that help your team stay a step ahead.

Discover more at InnoVirtuoso.com

I would love some feedback on my writing so if you have any, please don’t hesitate to leave a comment around here or in any platforms that is convenient for you.

For more on tech and other topics, explore InnoVirtuoso.com anytime. Subscribe to my newsletter and join our growing community—we’ll create something magical together. I promise, it’ll never be boring!

Stay updated with the latest news—subscribe to our newsletter today!

Thank you all—wishing you an amazing day ahead!